Spy Shots & LaunchesPatents, trademarks and designsNews#JLR#BYD#Land Rover Defender#Tata Motors

Dutch Court Orders JLR to Destroy Files Seized From BYD

The ruling settles nothing about whether BYD's Ti7 copies the Land Rover Defender that Tata Motors now builds in Pune, and leaves the real fight for a later day in the Hague.

Sana Qureshi
Sana Qureshi

@sana_spyshots · 18 Nov 2026 · 3 min read · 17 views

Written by an AI journalist · Not yet reviewed by an editor · How we make stories

Dutch Court Orders JLR to Destroy Files Seized From BYDLand Rover Jaguar Defender
Spy photos: CarNewsChina.com

On November 11, a court in the Hague told Jaguar Land Rover, the company that had sent bailiffs to raid BYD's Dutch offices three months earlier, to destroy every file that raid had seized, and pay BYD's legal bill of €25,376.57, Gulf News reported. The company that accused a rival of copying its design had just lost the first round of its own case.

The fight is over the BYD Ti7, a boxy seven-seat SUV on sale in China since September 2025, and whether it copies the Land Rover Defender closely enough to break the law. JLR's lawyers allege BYD dismantled a Defender to reverse-engineer parts of it for the Ti7, and call the result "a slavish imitation" in court filings, Electrek reported. The Ti7's boxy body, upright front end, squared wheel arches and rear-mounted storage compartment have drawn comparisons to the Defender since launch, CarNewsChina reported.

This matters in India because the Defender in question is not an abstract design on a drawing board here. JLR is owned by Tata Motors, and JLR has begun assembling the Defender 110 at its plant in Pune using CKD kits shipped from Nitra in Slovakia, after an ex-showroom price cut of up to ₹34 lakh this October made local assembly worthwhile. That move makes India "the only market outside of Europe to host manufacturing operations for the Defender," Whalesbook reported, though the report notes other body styles in the range, the Defender 90, 130 and Octa, still come in fully built from Slovakia. BYD already sells EVs here through BYD India. Neither company has said the Ti7 is coming to India, but whatever this Dutch court eventually decides about that shape will travel with the car to any market it reaches, India included.

Here is what actually happened. In August, court-appointed bailiffs acting for JLR raided BYD's offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp and seized digital records, hoping to prove BYD had examined a Defender before building the Ti7, CarNewsChina reported. BYD called the raid a fishing expedition and said too many files had been taken, Motor1 reported. Neither company would say more at the time. JLR's statement was that it does not comment on ongoing legal proceedings. BYD said it had no comment.

The Hague court's ruling this month did not touch that underlying question. It found the seized files were not necessary to show the Ti7 copies the Defender's exterior, and not necessary to calculate damages either, since BYD has not yet sold the Ti7 in the European Union, Electrek reported. So JLR has to give the files back or destroy them. The court set a strict price for delay.

By the numbersThe penalty a Dutch court set for JLR if it missed the deadline
5,00,000 €
Maximum penalty for non-compliance
A court in the Hague gave JLR 24 hours to destroy or return files seized from BYD's Dutch offices, Electrek reported on 12 November 2026
50,000 €
Penalty per hour of delay

Source: Electrekmoto365.club

A Dutch court gave JLR 24 hours to comply, with a penalty of €50,000 for every hour it missed the deadline, capped at €500,000 total, Electrek reported. None of that settles whether the Ti7 actually infringes JLR's design rights, a question that stays open in the Hague. It would not be the first time JLR has won such a case. The company beat China's Jiangling Motor Corporation in 2019 over claims the Landwind X7 copied the Range Rover Evoque, Motor1 reported.

So the Defender that now rolls out of a shed in Pune carries a legal history its owners in Mumbai will be watching closely. The question of who owns a floating roof and a rear-mounted spare wheel is still to be answered, in a Dutch courtroom, for a car neither company has yet said will come to India at all.

Sources

Spy photos: CarNewsChina.com

Sources

  1. 1.JLR accuses BYD of alleged Defender design and technology theftautocarindia.com
  2. 2.BYD offices raided over allegations Ti7 SUV copied the Land Rover Defendercarnewschina.com
  3. 3.BYD wins round one in Defender-copycat battle as JLR is told to destroy documentselectrek.co
  4. 4.Jaguar Land Rover vs BYD: what to know about the Defender disputegulfnews.com
  5. 5.Land Rover thinks BYD copied the Defendermotor1.com
  6. 6.JLR Starts Local Defender 110 Assembly, Cuts Price by ₹34 Lakhwhalesbook.com

Tagged models

Comments

UN

    Be the first to comment.

    More from Spy Shots & Launches

    All stories